Roof Replacements

Replacing Your Roof? What Part L Says About Insulation (North Dublin and Wicklow)

Does re-roofing mean you must upgrade insulation or hit a BER target? What Technical Guidance Document L 2022 says about roof work on existing Irish homes.

•8 min read•By Mihai Ariko
Replacing Your Roof? What Part L Says About Insulation (North Dublin and Wicklow)

When homeowners in Swords, Malahide, Greystones or Arklow start planning a new roof, a common question comes up early: "If we strip the roof, do the Building Regulations force us to insulate everything, or even bring the whole house up to a certain BER?"

The short answer is that a straightforward re-slate or re-tile usually does not trigger the big "major renovation" requirements. But the rules do expect sensible insulation standards for new work, and a roof replacement is often the cheapest moment you will ever have to improve it. This guide walks through what the official guidance actually says, so you can have an informed conversation with your roofer, designer or local building control authority.

This is general information, not legal or design advice. For a specific project, especially one that changes the roof structure or adds living space, talk to an architect, engineer or your local building control authority.

Where the rules come from

Energy performance of homes is covered by Part L of the Building Regulations ("Conservation of Fuel and Energy"). The Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage publishes Technical Guidance Document L 2022 – Dwellings, which explains how to comply. You can find it, along with the other Parts, on the Department's TGD L page.

Paragraph 0.1.3.1 of TGD L says the guidance applies to works to existing dwellings, including extensions, material alterations, material changes of use, major renovation and the replacement of external doors, windows and roof lights. Building Regulations apply whether or not your job needs planning permission.

What counts as a "major renovation"?

TGD L (paragraph 2.3.1) defines a major renovation as work where more than 25% of the surface of the dwelling envelope undergoes renovation. The envelope is the whole heat-loss surface of the house: walls, windows, floors and roof.

Where a home does undergo major renovation, paragraph 2.3.2 says the energy performance of the whole dwelling should be improved to the "cost optimal" level, insofar as this is technically, functionally and economically feasible. Paragraph 2.3.3 sets that level as 125 kWh/m²/yr calculated in DEAP (the official BER software), or carrying out a defined list of improvements.

That sounds daunting for a roof job. The detail is more reassuring.

Re-slating or re-tiling is not a major renovation

Table 6 of TGD L lists the works that count towards the 25% surface area. Under roofs, it lists replacement of roof structure. Note 3 to the same table is explicit: painting, re-plastering, rendering, re-slating, re-tiling, cavity wall insulation and insulation of ceiling are not considered major renovation works.

So for a typical North Dublin semi-d where the old concrete tiles, battens and felt are stripped and replaced on the existing rafters, the major renovation trigger is not reached by that work alone.

Table 7 goes further. Where the only work is a roof renovation (or roof and windows, or roof and floor), it marks the cost optimal upgrade as "not applicable". Note 4 explains it is not considered technically, functionally or economically feasible to bring the whole building to cost optimal level when replacing those elements.

When it can still apply

The picture changes when roof work is combined with other large jobs planned as a single project. Table 7 lists combinations such as external walls and roof renovation as triggering the cost optimal requirement. For those, the improvements include upgrading insulation at ceiling level where U-values are worse than Table 5, and, depending on age and efficiency, replacing an old oil or gas boiler or old storage heaters.

A large extension can also trigger it. Paragraph 2.3.6 says that where a new extension affects more than 25% of the existing dwelling's envelope, the completed dwelling should reach the cost optimal level.

Storm and defect repairs

Note 2 to Tables 6 and 7 says that where renovations to walls, roofs and ground floors are essential repairs, for example after fire, storm or flood damage or a material defect, it is not considered economically feasible to bring them to a cost optimal level. That is relevant after the kind of winter storms that hit exposed parts of Wicklow and the North Dublin coast. Our storm damage insurance checklist covers the practical side of those repairs.

Insulation standards for new roof work

Even when major renovation does not apply, Part L still expects reasonable insulation in new work done as a material alteration. Paragraph 2.1.2.5 refers to Table 5, which sets maximum U-values for material alterations and material changes of use. Note 2 to Table 5 says that for material alterations, the U-values relate to the new works.

For a pitched roof insulated at ceiling level (the usual attic setup in Irish semi-ds and bungalows), Table 5 gives an area-weighted average U-value of 0.16 W/m²K. The table sets separate, less demanding figures for roofs insulated on the slope and for flat roofs. Lower U-values mean less heat loss.

Whether your particular job is a "material alteration" depends on what is being changed, so ask your designer or building control authority if you are unsure. In practice, if the roof is being stripped anyway, it is worth agreeing the insulation build-up in writing before work starts. Ask:

  • Will insulation go at ceiling level (cold roof) or between and over/under the rafters (warm roof)?
  • What U-value will the finished roof achieve, and how was it calculated?
  • How will the eaves stay ventilated if attic insulation is increased?
  • Is a breathable membrane being used, and does the ventilation plan suit it?

Our guides to breathable membranes versus roofing felt and warm roof versus cold roof explain those options in more detail.

Do not trade heat for condensation

More insulation in a roof without proper ventilation can make the timbers colder and wetter. TGD L paragraph 2.3.8 says that where major renovation upgrades are carried out, care should be taken to comply with the ventilation requirements of Part F and Part J, and points to Clause 10 of the NSAI code of practice S.R. 54:2014 on energy efficient retrofit of dwellings. Paragraph 2.1.3.1 adds that thermal bridges should not pose a risk of surface or interstitial condensation.

The same thinking applies to smaller jobs. Insulation stuffed into the eaves, a blocked soffit vent or a bathroom fan venting into the attic are common causes of black mould and damp timbers in Irish roofs. See our guide to attic condensation and roof ventilation checks.

Older and protected houses

Period terraces in Dublin City, Victorian houses in Bray and Greystones, and protected structures need extra care. Paragraph 2.3.7 says that for buildings of architectural or historical interest or permeable traditional construction, the aim should be to improve the building as far as is reasonably practicable, without prejudicing its character or increasing the risk of long-term deterioration. Paragraph 0.6.5 adds that roof insulation should be achieved without damaging slating, either during the works or through condensation, and that obtrusive vents should not affect the character of the roof.

If your home is a protected structure, read our guide to roof repairs on protected structures before planning anything.

A quick planning checklist

Your projectWhat to think about
Re-slating or re-tiling on existing raftersNot a major renovation under Table 6. Agree insulation and ventilation details for any new work.
Topping up attic insulation at the same timeCeiling insulation is not a major renovation. Keep eaves ventilation clear. Check SEAI grant rules first.
Replacing the roof structureCounts towards the 25% envelope area. Ask your designer to check the total with any other works.
Roof plus external wall insulation as one projectCan trigger the cost optimal requirement (Table 7). Get a designer or BER assessor involved early.
Large extensionOver 25% of the existing envelope can trigger cost optimal (para 2.3.6).
Storm or defect repairsEssential repairs are not expected to reach cost optimal (Tables 6 and 7, note 2).

If you are hoping to use an SEAI grant for attic insulation, sort out any roof defects first. Our post on the SEAI attic insulation grant and roof repairs explains why.

Safety

Please do not climb onto your roof to check its condition. Photos from the ground, from an upstairs window or from inside the attic (standing only on boarded areas) are plenty for a roofer to give initial advice.

Talk to Perfect Roofing

We replace and repair roofs across Dublin City, North Dublin, South Dublin, Lucan, Bray, Wicklow, Naas and nearby areas. If you are planning a new roof, we can talk through the build-up, ventilation and what is realistic for your house, and work alongside your designer where a project needs one.

Contact us by WhatsApp, call 083 066 3462, or email hi@perfectroofing.ie.

Roofs, gutters, and Velux windows

Need a roofer to take a look?

Send a few photos on WhatsApp, email us, or tap the number to call. We cover Dublin City, North Dublin, South Dublin, Lucan, Bray, Wicklow, Naas, and nearby locations.

Related Articles

Discover more insights about roofing and home maintenance